The Menu
Sandwiches Served on a 7" White or Wheat Sub Roll
Upgrade to a 14" for only $6.55 more
Make it a Combo!
Add Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, or Coleslaw with a Soda for only $2.95
Add Chips and a Soda for only $2.69
Add Chips and a Soda for only $2.69
#1 The Vegetable Sandwich
Muenster & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato,Roasted Red Pepper, Cucumber, Red Onion,Italian Dressing & Mayo - $7.95
Add hummus - $0.75 · Add vegan chicken - $1.75
Add hummus - $0.75 · Add vegan chicken - $1.75
#2 Middle Class Club

Turkey, Ham, Bacon & Swiss with Lettuce,Tomato & Honey Mustard - $9.25
#3 Lake Street Italian

Ham, Capicola Salami, Pepperoni & Provolonewith Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Italian Dressing & Spices - $9.25
#4 Adult Club
Chicken Salad & Bacon with Lettuce,Tomato & Mayo - $9.25
#5 The PC
Turkey, Capicola & Provolone with Lettuce,Tomato, Mayo and Cherry Pepper Relish - $9.25
#6 Keep Up With The Jones'

Roast Beef, Turkey, Swiss & Cheddar with Lettuce,Tomato, Mayo & Horseradish - $9.75
#7 Hot Shot Italian

Grilled Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion,Italian Dressing & Spices - $9.25
#8 Three Pepper Chicken

Grilled Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato, Pepper Mix, and Mayo - $9.25
#9 New Yorker
Grilled Pastrami, Turkey & Swiss with Deli Mustard. Now with more meat! - $9.25
#10 BBQ Beef

BBQ Beef with Red Onions & Caffrey’s Signature BBQ Sauce - $9.25
#11 The Ranch Gobbler
Grilled Smoked Turkey, Melted Cheddarwith Lettuce, Tomato & Ranch Dressing - $9.25
#12 The Blue Cow

Grilled Roast Beef, Bleu Cheese Crumbles & Bacon with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion & Mayo - $10.25
#13 Simple Philly

Quality Grilled Steak & Provolone Cheese - $8.55
#14 Loaded Philly
Quality Grilled Steak, Grilled Onions, GreenPeppers, Mushrooms & Provolone Cheese - $8.95
#15 Italian Philly

Our Loaded Philly (above) With Grilled Pepperoni & Tomato Sauce - $9.55
#16 Simple Chicken Philly
Quality Grilled Chicken & Provolone Cheese - $8.55
#17 Loaded Chicken Philly
Quality Grilled Chicken, Grilled Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Provolone Cheese - $8.95
#18 Italian Chicken Philly

Our Loaded Chicken Philly (above) with Grilled Pepperoni & Tomato Sauce - $9.55
#19 Reuben

Quality Grilled Corned Beef with Kraut, 1,000Island & Swiss Cheese on Grilled Rye - $9.55
#20 Rachel
Reuben (see above) made with Turkey,Instead of Corned Beef on Grilled Rye - $9.55
#21 Grilled Cheese…PLEASE

Muenster, Provolone, Cheddar & Tomato on Grilled Sourdough - $7.25
#22 Hot Ham & Swiss
Quality Grilled Ham & Swiss with Mayo & Deli Mustard on Grilled Sourdough - $7.95
#23 Hot Pastrami

Grilled Pastrami, Swiss & Deli Mustardon Grilled Rye - $8.55
#24 Havin’ a Ball

Sliced Italian Meatballs, Tomato Sauce & Provolone Cheese on a 7” Sub Roll - $8.25
Classic Deli Subs
What Size?
Lite (2oz) - $5.95
Traditional (4oz) - $8.55
NY Deli (1/2 lb.) - $13.99
On What Bread?
White or Wheat
7” Sub Roll
Sliced Sourdough or Rye
Plain or Spinach Tortillas
PB & J - $4.50
Lite (2oz) - $5.95
Traditional (4oz) - $8.55
NY Deli (1/2 lb.) - $13.99
On What Bread?
White or Wheat
7” Sub Roll
Sliced Sourdough or Rye
Plain or Spinach Tortillas
PB & J - $4.50
Choose Your Favorite
• Turkey
• Ham & Swiss
• BLT
• Smoked Turkey
• Tuna Salad
• Egg Salad
• Roast Beef
• Chicken Salad
Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo
• Salami & Provolone
• Pastrami
• Corned Beef
Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mustard
• Ham & Swiss
• BLT
• Smoked Turkey
• Tuna Salad
• Egg Salad
• Roast Beef
• Chicken Salad
Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo
• Salami & Provolone
• Pastrami
• Corned Beef
Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mustard
Salads & Wraps
Get any salad AS A WRAP (dressing included) tucked into a plain or spinach tortilla
Garden Green - Full: $4.95 | Wrap: $4.95
Club - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Grilled Chicken - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Salad Salad - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Spinach - Half: $4.25 | Full: $6.95 | Wrap: $6.95
Caesar - Half: $4.25 | Full: $6.25 | Wrap: $5.85
Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Italian, Raspberry
Garden Green - Full: $4.95 | Wrap: $4.95
Club - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Grilled Chicken - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Salad Salad - Half: $4.75 | Full: $7.35 | Wrap: $7.55
Spinach - Half: $4.25 | Full: $6.95 | Wrap: $6.95
Caesar - Half: $4.25 | Full: $6.25 | Wrap: $5.85
Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Italian, Raspberry
Desserts
New York Style Cheesecake (topped w/ Blueberry, Cherry, Apple Cinnamon, or Chocolate Brownie) - $6.50
Plain Cheesecake - $4.95
Brownie - $2.99
Frosted Brownie - $3.50
Fresh Baked Cookies - $0.70 each
Three Cookies (Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Oatmeal, or Snicker Doodle) - $1.75
Big Chocolate Chip Cookie - $1.99
Carrot Cake - $3.95
Rice Krispie Treat - $3.65
Blondie - $2.25
Sebastian Joe's Ice Cream - $7.95
(Oreo, Raspberry Chocolate Chip, Salty Caramel, Vanilla, Chocolate, Pavaroti - Banana/Caramel/Chocolate Chip)
Plain Cheesecake - $4.95
Brownie - $2.99
Frosted Brownie - $3.50
Fresh Baked Cookies - $0.70 each
Three Cookies (Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Oatmeal, or Snicker Doodle) - $1.75
Big Chocolate Chip Cookie - $1.99
Carrot Cake - $3.95
Rice Krispie Treat - $3.65
Blondie - $2.25
Sebastian Joe's Ice Cream - $7.95
(Oreo, Raspberry Chocolate Chip, Salty Caramel, Vanilla, Chocolate, Pavaroti - Banana/Caramel/Chocolate Chip)
Drinks
Gold Peak Tea (Sweet, Unsweetened) - $2.29
Cans of Soda (Coke Products & Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, & Dr. Pepper) - $1.15
Dasani - $1.25
Powerade - $2.29
Honest Tea (Half & Half / Green Tea) - $2.49
San Pellegrino - $2.29
Cans of Soda (Coke Products & Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, & Dr. Pepper) - $1.15
Dasani - $1.25
Powerade - $2.29
Honest Tea (Half & Half / Green Tea) - $2.49
San Pellegrino - $2.29
Extra Meats
Meat - $1.75
Chicken Breast - $1.50
Vegan Chicken - $1.75
Steak - $2.50
Bacon - $1.25
Scoop o' Chicken Salad - $3.50
Scoop o' Tuna Salad - $3.50
Scoop o' Egg Salad - $3.50
Chicken Breast - $1.50
Vegan Chicken - $1.75
Steak - $2.50
Bacon - $1.25
Scoop o' Chicken Salad - $3.50
Scoop o' Tuna Salad - $3.50
Scoop o' Egg Salad - $3.50
Extra Veggies, Cheese & Sauces
Jalapenos - FREE
Banana Peppers - FREE
Roasted Red Peppers - $.50
Cherry Pepper Relish - $.50
Hummus - $.75
Real Horseradish - $.50
Cheese - $1.00
Side of Dressing - $.50
Pepper Mix - $.50
Cucumber - $.50
Red Onion - FREE
Mayo - FREE
Tomato - FREE
Lettuce - FREE
Oil/Vinegar - FREE
Mustard - FREE
Side Items
Italian Pasta - $1.85
Macaroni Salad - $1.85
Potato Salad - $1.85
Sliced Fresh Fruit - $2.99
Coleslaw - $1.85
Chips - $1.49
(Jalapeno Kettle Chips/ Salt & Vinegar Kettle Chips / BBQ Kettle Chips / Regular Lays / Harvest Cheddar Sun Chips / Garden Salsa Sun Chips / Lays Sour Cream & Onion / Baked Lays / Nacho Cheese Doritos / Cool Ranch Doritos)
Macaroni Salad - $1.85
Potato Salad - $1.85
Sliced Fresh Fruit - $2.99
Coleslaw - $1.85
Chips - $1.49
(Jalapeno Kettle Chips/ Salt & Vinegar Kettle Chips / BBQ Kettle Chips / Regular Lays / Harvest Cheddar Sun Chips / Garden Salsa Sun Chips / Lays Sour Cream & Onion / Baked Lays / Nacho Cheese Doritos / Cool Ranch Doritos)
Sandwich Special
Half "Lite" Deli Special & Half Salad or Cup of Soup - $8.50
Pickles
Whole Dill Pickle - $.95 each
Half Dill Pickle - $.55 each
Jalapeno Pickle Spears - $.30 each
Soup
Chicken Wild Rice
Beef Chili
Vegan Chili
Baja Chicken Enchilada
Italian Sausage w/ Cheese Tortellini
Tomato Basil
Broccoli & Cheddar
Loaded Baked Potato
Chicken Noodle
Vegetarian & Vegan Soup (Call the Store for the Daily Option)
Cup - $4.95 Bowl - $5.55
Beef Chili
Vegan Chili
Baja Chicken Enchilada
Italian Sausage w/ Cheese Tortellini
Tomato Basil
Broccoli & Cheddar
Loaded Baked Potato
Chicken Noodle
Vegetarian & Vegan Soup (Call the Store for the Daily Option)
Cup - $4.95 Bowl - $5.55